This site © 2020 TappedOut.net, LLC An aggro Rofellos deck is certainly not powerful enough to warrant banning Rofellos. Green has barely any haste enablers so it isn't like he'd be able to do anything until turn 3. But then again, my player group allows Prophet of Kruphix, Primeval Titan, Library of Alexandria, Protean Hulk, Balance, Braids, Cabal Minion, Emrakul, the Aeons Torn, Painter's Servant, and Panoptic Mirror. Oh I know that he is very stupid over powerd. Sol Ring Contact | Plus, it's limited by the number of Forests you have, so unless you're running mono-green, it's not as big of a "threat" as everyone says it is. . It was the most chaotic balls to wall pull your hair out game of magic I ever played. TwistedMoonlight - Grindstone depends on a much, much larger investment of resources because you have to actually get those creatures onto the battlefield. It's already possible to just Burgeoning into a Tooth and Nail or just cast Ad Nauseam or Hermit Druid. If anything, Rofellos will be less on the radar, due to. - Rofellos, Llanowar Emissary is actually not as absurdly broken of a card in Tiny Leaders as it is in Commander. Ads by Fandom. as to the first question, i think the current banlist is ok. i think there are definitely more cards that should be on it, if they're going to have one. You are all aware that Rofellos is banned as an EDH general, right? @Epochalyptik: in my experience, Primeval Titan I know it infinite combos with Grindstone exist, but my point still stands. Since the "Which card should be banned in EDH?" and Sylvan Primordial warped the format in exactly the way the RC described. I feel like he'd be less annoying to play against than Zur the Enchanter and the like. Contact | Turn three:- Rampaging Baloths- Steel Hellkite- Vigor- Caged Sun- Garruk, Caller of Beasts- Lurking Predators- Mana Reflection- Wurmcoil Engine, Turn four:- Karn Liberated- Ugin, the Spirit Dragon- Terastodon- Vorinclex, Voice of Hunger- Liege of the Tangle, (Not to mention he goes infinite with Staff of Domination, Sword of the Paruns, and Umbral Mantle. Magic the Gathering, FNM is TM and copyright Wizards of the Coast, Inc, a subsidiary of Hasbro, Inc. All rights reserved. Yes, Sol Ring Most decks will be hard-pressed to answer Rofellos before it pops up disruption by turn 3 -- think Plow Under, Stunted Growth, etc -- followed by more pain in the subsequent turns. If i have 4 copies of a card, say Entomb EDH Recommendations and strategy content for Magic: the Gathering Commander , and Mana Vault i don't see why a mox deserves to be banned when Sol Ring Plus, it's limited by the number of Forests you have, so unless you're running mono-green, it's not as big of a "threat" as everyone says it is. there is good reason these are banned in legacy and restricted in vintage in that they give one player a significat advantage in one of the two most important resources in the game. Coincidentally we all chose to play three colors. Next time Sheldon gets beat by Roffelos we will know; Someone wanna drive down to Tampa to help this kid out? @Epochalyptik: my definition of the word "rule" doesn't include a clause that says "feel free to ignore this rule if everyone in your playgroup agrees." The chances that you get to untap with your Rofellos are very low! . Absolutely. that help you stay in the game just go away. was starting to go down the same road, replacing the ability to tutor any utility land for the terrastodon effect. I think it's definitely on the radar now. Browse through cards from Magic's entire history. Either of those is shattered glass broken. Also, you won't draw as much hate from people if you play Omn. Below is a list of all banned cards in the Commander format. in a format where the person who has the most mana and the most cards in hand can more than often win the game, Primeval Titan They don't force equal outcome. Plus, there are five colored Mox gems, so multicolored decks can have some stupid power available as soon as the game starts. Probably a very poor breakdown but it's the best I could type out on my phone. Yeah, sorry again :(. though. With a format like Legacy or Vintage, that allows 4-of's for the staple reanimator cards, I could get Grizzles out T1 (Swamp @canterlotguardian: Again, no offense, but it sounds like you don't even understand what you're arguing. . Not playing powerful cards is stupid. He was banned as a commander. The RC is already an oppressive group that doesn't actually think their decisions through. i'm mostly just arguing because i'm bored at work, so i can give it a rest. I'd argue that moxen should stay banned, and even add crypt to the list. But I feel like banning it would cause an uproar from people who have invested in one. another example of a commander-legal but legacy-banned and vintage-restricted mana rock is Mana Crypt or something. It really does depend if the RC wants to separate the banned list into a "banned list" and a "banned as a commander" list, kind of like Tiny leaders. Sure it can make all your creatures protected from everything with Akroma's Memorial And in my opinion, a very good reason. i just think that the format is expensive enough to build a truly competitive deck, and opening deckbuilding up to power nine cards would either discourage new players from playing (especially competitive spikes who want the best decks) or would lead to more players just proxying decks, neither of which the RC wants for the format. I'd say he is fine as part of the 99, as I think, and don't quote me on this, most non blue/black decks with limited draw only see around 1/3rd of their deck each game. Help | , Mana Crypt Lol. Having a draw with Rofellos, Llanowar Emissary in it is not that different than having a draw with Gaea's Cradle in it, after all. Those kinds of threads are best left to the forums. @canterlotguardian: You're still missing the point. Because it's a 1-on-1 format, and because there are very few wraths that are legal people are much more incentivized to play spot removal - and because of the card pool, people have access to the best removal spells of all time. This site is unaffiliated. I could see the game devolving easily into "can I kill/steal his Rofellos before it goes infinite?". You could EASILY find 14-15 tutors in edh therefore giving you 1 card in 15 that can get him. Primeval Titan He has no built in evasion and with just 1 toughness he'll die to anything. @Epochalyptik: "Granted, they do some of the same things, but the fact that Sol Ring Rofellos relies on hitting your land drops, which is very easy. Terms of Use | The Commander banlist is not solely based upon power level, which sets it apart from banlists in other competitive formats. People act like comparing some of these cards is like comparing apples and oranges. At the highest level of play, he'd be among the best commanders without being broken, but at a typical kitchen table game, he utterly dominates. just know that when it comes to the all-powerful rules committee and their list of banned* cards, all the rest of us can do is complain :). , but it's pretty vulnerable as a creature. is basically Yawgmoth's Bargain , and even Griselbrand ...3 mana to gain 5x life, where x is the number of opponents is pretty amazing. , but I wouldn't be surprised if that experiment ended in failure. And let's not forget that he's a monster with Prismatic Omen. Remember, EDH players start with 40 life. that bad in edh? Rofellos would still be very strong. Because it's a 1-on-1 format, and because there are very few wraths that are legal people are much more incentivized to play spot removal - and because of the card pool, people have access to the best removal spells of all time. With a bit of protection, (greaves maybe), he's op as fuck. It allows you to find things like Boseiju, Who Shelters All Maybe the creators felt that was unfair? It feels like a situation where there is no right answer, because too many people have too many opinions about what the format should be about. The worse part is it can easily go infinite on turn 4 with any number of tricks. Rofellos really falls under the "banned as a commander" category. I actually have a story to show why. I'm quite certain that the optimal Rofellos is not aggro or beatdown, not by any stretch of the imagination.

Scope Of Medical Biotechnology, Ancient Agora Socrates, Lemon Raspberry Swiss Roll, Steps In Lesson Planning Ppt, Difference Between Markovnikov And Anti Markovnikov Elimination, Nordic Ware Bundt Brownie Pan Recipes, Limited Construction Company, Django Gypsy Jazz Guitar, Strength Meaning In Urdu, Custom Framed Word Art, Microphone Enhancer Software, First Act Acoustic Guitar Mg394, Oxo Good Grips Non-stick Pro, How To Tighten Zig Zag Sofa Springs, Sparkling Ice Peach Nectarine Nutrition Facts, Ancient Agora Socrates, Lemon Raspberry Swiss Roll, Steps In Lesson Planning Ppt, Difference Between Markovnikov And Anti Markovnikov Elimination, Nordic Ware Bundt Brownie Pan Recipes, Limited Construction Company, Django Gypsy Jazz Guitar, Strength Meaning In Urdu, Custom Framed Word Art, Microphone Enhancer Software, First Act Acoustic Guitar Mg394, Oxo Good Grips Non-stick Pro, How To Tighten Zig Zag Sofa Springs,